Philosophy
The Art of Thinking
Philosophy, after all, is not an exact science. We cannot measure the accuracy, applicability or viability of one philosophy against another the way we measure the performance of an engineering system or the accuracy of a mathematical calculation. Philosophy, much like psychology and sociology, deals with human experience, perception, values, and the interpretation of the world. Different people, shaped by different cultures, upbringings, social conditions, education, and personal experiences, naturally develop different ways of understanding life.
There is no single philosophy that can universally explain every aspect of human existence. Philosophical arguments can be examined for their logic, consistency, and supporting evidence, but that does not make every philosophical conclusion an objective or universal truth.
Yet one of the greatest mistakes people make is treating the words of famous philosophers as though they carry unquestionable authority simply because of the reputation of the person who said them.
Throughout my life, I have encountered people who repeatedly quote Nietzsche, Kant, Marx, Plato, and other famous thinkers, often without understanding the circumstances, assumptions, or historical context in which those ideas were developed. Their quotations become expressions of intellectual status rather than genuine attempts to understand or explain something.
This has always troubled me.
Philosophers are products of their times, cultures, personal circumstances, and intellectual environments. They possess exceptional abilities in certain areas, but they also have limitations, biases, and imperfections like everyone else.
Why, then, should we take their words out of context, turn them into guiding principles for our own lives, and misuse them to challenge opposing views or our own or simply to demonstrate how intellectually sophisticated we are to prove a point?
It is intellectually and morally reprehensible to parrot famous philosophers and surrender the responsibility to think independently.
My argument is not that philosophers’ ideas should be dismissed. Quite the opposite. They deserve recognition for their intellectual contributions, but recognition should not become unquestioning admiration.
A philosopher's reputation should never be mistaken for proof that the philosopher is right as much as a name of an artist must never be the way to evaluate their artistic value of their work.
Throughout my life, I have read the works of many philosophers and developed great respect for their intellectual abilities, their willingness to question established beliefs, and their efforts to understand the deeper meaning of things. But I have also come to question the way philosophy itself is presented, practiced, and understood.
My central argument is simple: Philosophers are, first and foremost, deep and critical thinkers. What distinguishes them is not the sophistication of their language, but their ability to question what others take for granted.
Consider some of history's most influential philosophers.
Socrates questioned accepted knowledge and encouraged people to examine their own beliefs. Plato sought to distinguish appearance from reality. Aristotle investigated the causes and fundamental principles of things. Descartes questioned what we could know with certainty. Kant explored the limits of human reason and knowledge. Nietzsche challenged inherited morality and conventional values. Marx examined economic relationships and class structures, arguing that understanding the world should lead to changing it.
These thinkers reached different conclusions, sometimes contradicting one another. Yet they had something fundamental in common: they questioned accepted assumptions and attempted to understand the underlying nature of things.
But is this process exclusive to philosophers?
I do not believe so.
Consider an engineer trying to determine why a complex system is malfunctioning. The engineer begins with observations, develops possible explanations, questions assumptions, and investigates underlying causes. A theory is developed, tested, challenged, and modified until a satisfactory explanation emerges. A physician follows a similar intellectual process when diagnosing an illness. Scientists formulate hypotheses, mathematicians construct logical arguments and proofs, and lawyers examine evidence and interpretations. Even literature explores the complexities of human existence, morality, and relationships through different methods.
Each discipline has its own tools and standards, but all require the ability to think critically, examine assumptions, and question conclusions.
Philosophy should be approached with the same intellectual discipline. Its ideas should be examined, challenged, and explained and the adopted and not for any other reason. This brings me to what I consider one of the greatest problems with philosophy: its language.
Many philosophers express their ideas in such abstract and elaborate terms that even educated readers struggle to understand them. Concepts that may have relatively simple foundations become surrounded by complicated terminology, excessive explanations, and sometimes entirely new and totally made-up parlance and lexicon or definitions created by the philosophers themselves.
I have encountered philosophical arguments in which thinkers appear so entangled in their own maze of terminology and elaborate reasoning that often they contradict themselves, sometimes without clearly recognizing the contradictions. Instead of clarifying their ideas, they become trapped in the intellectual structures they have created.
Certainly, complex ideas sometimes require specialized language and precise wording. But complexity of thought and complexity of expression are not necessarily the same thing. An idea does not become more profound simply because it is difficult to understand.
In my view, this unnecessary complexity has helped turn philosophy into something resembling an intellectual luxury, almost a fashionable possession reserved for a privileged group.
Philosophy becomes something to display rather than something to understand. Individuals who have mastered its terminology can quote selected passages, invoke famous names, and demonstrate their intellectual sophistication without necessarily examining the substance of the arguments.
The philosopher becomes an authority, and philosophical language becomes a symbol of intellectual status.
I have seen similar tendencies in religious discussions, where people become so absorbed in definitions, interpretations, and semantic arguments that the original question gets lost. Instead of addressing the substance of an argument, they shift the discussion toward terminology, forcing others to defend the meanings of their words rather than examine the underlying idea.
Language, which should serve as a tool for understanding, becomes a tool for intellectual dominance.
This is precisely what philosophy should avoid.
Consider Nietzsche, whose ideas about power have sometimes been reduced to the expression "might makes right" and used to justify authoritarianism or even fascism. Whether one agrees with Nietzsche or not, his philosophy cannot be adequately understood through such a simplified interpretation.
The same problem arises whenever people take fragments of philosophical writings and use them to support beliefs they already hold, without understanding the reasoning behind them. The value of reading philosophy lies as much in understanding the process of thinking as in understanding the final conclusions.
I believe philosophical ideas should first be presented in clear and accessible language. Those who wish to explore them further can then examine their deeper implications, complexities, and possible contradictions. This would not diminish philosophy. It would make it more meaningful and allow more people to participate in examining and improving philosophical ideas.
An idea that can be understood by many can also be challenged by many. An idea hidden behind layers of obscure language risks becoming protected from criticism, not because it is necessarily correct, but because few people can understand what is being claimed.
I am not suggesting that every complicated idea can be reduced to a simple sentence or that specialized terminology has no place in philosophy. My argument is that sophistication should arise from the depth and quality of reasoning, not from the ability to manipulate words.
Philosophers deserve recognition for their intellectual contributions. But they should not be placed on pedestals, and their writings should not be treated as sacred texts.
Their greatest contribution may not be the answers they provided, but the questions they taught us to ask.
Ultimately, philosophy should not belong to a privileged intellectual class or to those who have mastered the art of elaborate expression. It belongs to anyone willing to question, investigate, reason, and reconsider what they believe.
Philosophy should not be measured by how difficult it is to understand, but by how effectively it helps us understand. And perhaps the greatest achievement of philosophy would be to make itself accessible enough that people no longer feel they must be philosophers to think philosophically.